Bad news. The news is out that the merger of Rogers and Shaw has been approved by the Canadian government:
Federal Industry Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne is set to make an announcement this morning about Rogers Communications Inc.’s proposed $26-billion purchase of Shaw Communications Inc.
A senior government official, speaking on the condition they not be named in order to discuss matters not yet made public, says the minister will discuss the transfer of wireless licences at a news conference before the stock market opens.
The deal was first announced more than two years ago and has been awaiting regulatory approval since then.
A full-scale purchase of Shaw by Rogers raised competition concerns, and the original deal has been revised to include the sale of Shaw’s Freedom Mobile to Quebec-based Videotron.
The CRTC and Competition Bureau have each given the agreement the green light.
So, if Canadians were hoping that this deal would not be approved and that competition, as little as it is in the Canadian telco space, wouldn’t shrink any further will be disappointed in this news. All this is going to do for Canadians is reduce choice and increase prices because there are less players in the market. I was going to say that I don’t understand why nobody in Ottawa sees that. But instead I will say that I don’t understand why nobody in Ottawa cares because Canada pays some of the highest prices in the world for telco services and this issue gets lip service at best from the Canadian government. And to be honest, I don’t know what it will take to change that.
Today is a very sad day in Canada.
The Canadian Government Put Strings On The Rogers/Shaw Merger….. Not That It Makes A Difference….
Posted in Commentary with tags Rogers, Shaw, Videotron on April 1, 2023 by itnerdYesterday the Rogers/Shaw merger got approved by the Canadian government. That means less competition and higher prices for Canadians. But if you believe the Canadian government (Spoiler alert: I don’t) there are guardrails in place to make sure that this is a good deal for Canadians. Here’s the TL:DR for your perusal:
“As part of these agreements and conditions, Videotron:
“Separately, Rogers will also be subject to strict and legally binding commitments requiring them to make major investments to improve connectivity within the next 5 years, including:
“These agreements are subject to significant financial damages for non-compliance: up to $200 million in the case of Videotron and up to $1 billion in the case of Rogers. These agreements will be released publicly and are subject to annual reporting requirements.
“Should the parties fail to live up to any of their commitments, our government will use every means in our power to enforce the terms on behalf of Canadians.
Now that all sounds good and the potential fines sound big. Not to mention the potential fines are meant to encourage Videotron and Rogers to do everything on this list. But call me a skeptic, I really don’t see any of this bringing about more competition and lower prices. The problem with the Canadian telco space is that it’s an oligopoly. And this deal does nothing to address that. Until the folks in Ottawa figure out that there has to be a big foreign player that is allowed to enter the Canadian market, Canadians will continue to pay among the highest prices for their telco services.
1 Comment »